In September the Government opened its consultation ‘Modernising Corporate Reporting to support long-term economic growth’. The consultation spans several areas of corporate reporting; this Ellason Lens provides a summary of our response to the remuneration-related questions (our full consultation response can be found on our website).
Disclosure proposals
Remuneration reporting has expanded significantly in volume and scope since the Greenbury Report in 1995 formalised the reporting framework. The original emphasis was on providing shareholders with a transparent account of executive remuneration decisions and the information needed to hold remuneration committees to account. Subsequent requirements have extended reporting to broader matters beyond that focus. Ellason is supportive of the consultation’s aim of simplifying and removing certain disclosures.
We have tested the proposed reporting changes against two principles: i) does the current reporting requirement add little value to the investor’s understanding of pay decisions and their link to the commercial ambition, and ii) can the disclosure be better addressed through the UK Corporate Governance Code, taking advantage of the greater flexibility to provide information that is meaningful in the company’s context.
Our response to each proposal is summarised below; our rationale is available in our full response.
| Disclosure item | Government proposal | Ellason response |
|---|---|---|
| Single total figure (no change to methodology needed) | Retain | ✓ Agree |
| Disclosure of performance measures applied to previous year’s pay | Retain | ✓ Agree |
| Forward-looking directors’ remuneration policy | Retain | ✓ Agree |
| 10-year TSR chart alongside CEO pay for those years | Retain | ✗ Disagree |
| Include information on how policy will be implemented | Remove or streamline | ✗ Disagree |
| Disclose information on directors’ accumulated shareholdings | Remove or streamline | ✗ Disagree |
| CEO-employee pay ratio1 | Remove | ✓ Agree |
| Relative importance of spend on pay | Remove | ✓ Agree |
| Executive directors’ pay prior to the company’s listing | Remove | ✓ Agree |
| Illustration of pay with 50% share price appreciation | Remove | ✓ Agree |
| Work of remuneration committee including parties providing advice to it1 | Remove | ✓ Agree |
| Malus and clawback2 | Remove | ✗ Disagree |
| Engagement with shareholders, employees and alignment with wider employee pay practices1 | Remove | ✓ Agree |
| Addressing shareholder dissent and disclosure of AGM votes | Remove | ✗ Disagree |
- 1.Is a ‘comply or explain’ disclosure under the UK Corporate Governance Code
- 2.While a reporting obligation exists under the UK Corporate Governance Code, malus and clawback are important governance safeguards and therefore we believe disclosure should remain a statutory requirement, rather than being on a ‘comply or explain’ basis
Voting proposals
We do not support the removal of the annual advisory vote on remuneration. Removing the vote would not reduce annual shareholder scrutiny; investors we have engaged with have indicated that they would express those concerns by opposing other resolutions, such as the re-election of directors.
We propose the removal of the three-yearly binding Remuneration Policy vote, which better achieves the consultation’s objective of simplifying reporting, reducing administrative burdens and making UK companies more attractive to investment. This approach would give non-executive directors greater flexibility, particularly on recruitment, to respond to the company’s remuneration needs while preserving shareholder scrutiny.
If both votes are retained, we recommend removing the three-year approval cycle for the Remuneration Policy. Companies would seek approval only when a new Policy is needed, avoiding a resource-intensive review when circumstances are unchanged. This aligns with the current approach for shareholder approval on long-term incentive plans.
The consultation closes on 30 November. This is an important opportunity to help shape the future of the DRR and the voting regime, and we encourage our clients and contacts to share their views.
Please do not hesitate to contact any of the Ellason team should you wish to discuss this topic further.